Official
Gadgeteer Hands On Review: Swiss Army Broadcast PDA / Cell
Phone Case by Julie Strietelmeier Last date revised: 09/03/2001 |
Product Requirements:
Device:
Palm III series (not including IIIc), Palm VII
series, Palm V series
What is the first image that comes to mind when I say the words: Swiss Army? For me, I think of those nifty red pocket knifes with a multitude of blades (I love the tweezers!). What about PDA cases, did that image pop up for you? Yeah, me neither... But that will be changing as there is now an entire line of Palm specific leather PDA cases made by Swiss Army. Although I reviewed their Code V case for the Palm V earlier this year, these new cases are a little more interesting because they have an ingenious method of securing the PDA to the case. More about that in a minute.
The Broadcast is a zippered book style case made of black Italian leather specifically for the Palm III series, Palm VII series or Palm V series PDAs and a cell phone. At first glance it looks like many similar book style cases except that it has a smaller cell phone holder attached to it. But what really makes this case different, is the method used to attach the PDA to the case. Instead of using Velcro (can you say ECK), the case comes with 3 plastic quick-release clips. One clip for each Palm model (Palm III, VII or V). Unfortunately, there isn't a clip for the Palm IIIc, m100 or m500 series yet. This doesn't mean that you can't use those PDAs with this case though. The case comes with Velcro that you can attach to various PDAs to hold them in. I found that the case worked fine with the Compaq iPAQ (naked or with the CF sleeve), Casio E-100 series, Visor Prism, and HP 548. It will basically work with any PDA that can fit into 5 1/2" H x 4" W x 1 5/8" D.
The special clips have two heavy duty snaps on them which match up with two mating snaps on the inside of the case. You just snap the correct clip to the back of your Palm and then snap the PDA into the case. Voila, the PDA is now securely in place!
Putting the clips on the back of the PDA is pretty easy. Getting them off is a little more difficult, but not too bad. With a little practice, I was able to pop them off with one hand. The only real problem with these clips are that they cover up the hotsync port. So, you will have to totally remove them to sync in the cradle. If they had left an opening, you could at least use a cable to sync. As it is, your only option for not removing the clip is to sync via IR.
The case construction is pretty rugged. The front and back of the case are padded and have really rigid stiffeners. The screen cover portion of the case has 3 card slots with one slot having a see thru window and a plastic pull out tray. This works great for pulling out your drivers license for display. Behind these card slots is a large slot that can be used for currency or other small papers. The whole interior of the case is lined in black leather which makes it look and feel more substantial.
On the outside of the cover is a cell phone holder. This holder has a leather top with black elastic sides. Cell phones less than 5" H x 2" W x 1" D should fit in the holder just fine. A leather loop with a heavy duty snap keeps the cell phone from falling out of this holder.
The back of the case has a leather covered belt clip. This is the type of clip that just slides over the belt or waist band. There is nothing to keep the case being pushed up and off your belt accidentally. Due to that fact, I wouldn't recommend wearing this case on your belt.
The Broadcast is a zippered case and as such, it has a black nylon zipper around three sides of the case. A nice padded black leather pull with the Swiss Army logo hangs from the slider part of the zipper. Zipper action is smooth and free from sticking or jamming. However, it is a bit stiff. I'm sure that will loosen with use though.
This is a nicely constructed case that can do triple service as a PDA case, wallet and cell phone holder. Because of the padding, I believe it will protect your PDA easily from the effects of a short drop. The only trouble I see with the Broadcast is it's size. Because it is so large, there is no way it will fit in a pocket. So, this is a case that you will either be carrying around in your hand, or another bag. If you don't mind the size, this is a quality case that looks good and protects well.
Price: $75.00 Available at StylusCentral and other PDA stores
Pros:
Secure PDA attachment method
Includes a cell phone holder
Cons:
Large
Have to remove clip to sync with desktop
Belt clip can slide off belt easily
Let me know your comments
on the Swiss Army Broadcast PDA / Cell Phone Case and read what others have to say. Back to Main Page. |