Official Gadgeteer Hands On Review: Kodak PalmPix for the Palm III and m100
by Julie Strietelmeier and Judie Clark
Last date revised: 04/11/2001

Product Requirements:
Device:
Palm III or m100 Series
PalmPix.PRC 61k
Approx. 100k per picture

Desktop:
Windows Systems: Windows 95, 95B (OS R/2), 98, 98SE, 2000, NT 4.0 with Service Pack 3 or higher, PC with a minimum 486 processor, Minimum of 16 MB RAM, Minimum of 20 MB hard disk space, CD-ROM drive, Color Monitor with 256 colors (16-bit color recommended)
Macintosh Systems: Palmconnect Kit, PowerMac system, Macintosh OS 7.5.5 to 9.04 inclusive, Minimum of 16 MB RAM, Minimum of 20 MB hard disk space, CD-ROM drive, Available USB port, Color monitor with 256 colors (16-bit color recommended)

The Kodak Palmpix Series of digital cameras are designed to clip onto the bottom of either the Palm III or the Palm m100 series PDAs, and soon the Palm m500 series. What sets them apart from other digital cameras is the fact that they have no moving parts, no memory card, no film, no "Ready" light, no flash, and no zoom lens; but once attached to your Palm, it turns that regular PDA into a "digital camera with a 2X digital zoom".

Included in the box:
Kodak PalmPix Camera for the Palm III or m100 Handheld, Kodak Photolife AAA Alkaline Battery, Camera User's Guide, Quick Setup Guide, Registration Card, CD ROM with software, including: PalmPix Macintosh Conduit, PalmPix Windows Conduit, PalmPix Application for Palm III or m100 Handheld, ArcSoft PhotoImpression 2000 Software

The Kodak software is easy to install. You simply insert the disk, and choose your options.

The PalmPix also includes ArcSoft PhotoImpression 2000 Software, which is capable of allowing you to edit and enhance digital pictures you have taken. There are a variet of functions available, and the best thing you can do is take some time and really explore this software...play with it, and be creative with some of the pictures you will take.

Making the PalmPix camera work is as easy as hot-syncing the PalmPix application to your Palm, and then attaching the camera module itself to the serial port connection on the bottom of the Palm. A PalmPix icon will then appear in your launcher. 

To activate the PalmPix, you simply tap the icon. You will come to a Image List screen, which looks basically like the filing program that it is.

On this screen, you are presented with several options: You can set the self-timer, decide what quality or resolution pictures you would like to take, or view how many pictures are still available to be taken - based on available memory and resolution chosen. 

Resolutions available include Good: 320 x 240 and Better: 640 x 480. You set the resolution by tapping one of the two size boxes at the bottom of the screen - one will highlight, showing that it has been selected. Obviously, the lower the resolution, the more pictures you will be able to take. The pictures are saved to the PDA's memory.

Once pictures have been taken, they are listed by a number, then time and date stamped. You may file the pictures by different categories provided, or edit and create your own categories.

It is possible to beam images to another Palm, by accessing the Record menu. It is also possible to select which images are uploaded or deleted, by accessing the Options menu. You have to actually delete the pictures from the PDA. They will not automatically delete when you hotsync.

There is a detailed FAQ available on the Kodak site, if you have any specific questions that we don't address in this review.

One thing you might want to consider, especially if you have a 2MB PDA, is the use of a storage device, such as the Memory Safe or the Flash Plug. Both devices can substantially add to your device's ability to take and save more pictures.

PalmPix for the Palm III Series
by Julie Strietelmeier

The Palm III series PalmPix can interface with the Palm III, IIIc, IIIe, IIIx, IIIxe, VII, IBM Workpad and TRGPro PDAs. I used it with the Palm IIIc for my review. 

One of the first things that I noticed was the lack of a lens cover or storage pouch. I could live without a storage pouch, but I really think a small cap of some type should be included to protect the camera lens. It would be very easy for a foreign object to scratch the lens while the PalmPix was at the bottom of a gear bag or pocket.

The clip-on module adds a little weight to the PDA (0.1 lbs/45g) but not near as much as a full sized digital camera. 

The camera is powered by 2 AAA batteries. So far, the camera doesn't appear to be a battery hog. I still have the same set of batteries in the PalmPix that were included with the package.

The PalmPix is made of plastic but feels very sturdy. It snaps on to the bottom of the Palm IIIc easily. Removing it requires you to just pull it off. I would rather that it had spring loaded clips like the original Palm Modem as they would make removal easier.

When the PalmPix is attached, you hold the PDA horizontal with the screen facing you. This becomes your viewfinder. The actual lens points out the back (away from you). 

 

A small rubber grip helps you hold onto the PDA/PalmPix configuration. Holding the PDA this way feels pretty comfortable and quite camera-like. 

You use your thumb to press the shutter button which is the DateBook application button. One press to this button will turn the viewfinder (the PDA display) on. Another press will capture a picture. The viewfinder is pretty sluggish but it does change as you move the camera around and the picture that you see isn't very clear. It's really pixilated. I noticed that the viewfinder is black and white even while using the IIIc. Although you can view the pictures in color on the IIIc. One other thing that I noticed was that you can not turn off the Palm while it is in the viewfinder mode. The power button has no effect. 

I had a lot of trouble using the PalmPix with my Palm IIIc outdoors. The color screen made for a horrible viewfinder. It would be great if the PalmPix also had a regular viewfinder that you could look thru to help line up a shot.

The PalmPix isn't really speedy as far as capturing a picture and writing it into PDA memory. I did some timing tests and found that it took approximately 10 secs from snap to finish for the small size (320 x 240) pictures and 15 secs for the large size pictures (640 x 480). So you can't expect to take pictures in rapid succession.

For those of you that are photographers, here are the camera specs:

Color CMOS Imager
2X digital zoom
Fixed focus f/2.0, 6.1mm focal length
Shutter speed: 1/15 - 1/500 seconds
Focus range: 36" to infinity
Automatic exposure and white balance
File formats: JPEG, BMP in 24 bit color

As far as picture quality, I found that the camera was pretty much all over the place. Sometimes the pictures that I took were pretty clear and sharp and other times they were quite blurry. Almost all the pictures came out somewhat grainy. I think that lighting plays a major part in how well the pics turn out. Low light conditions and really bright conditions make for very poor photos. You need the light to be 'just right'.

You can check out some of my non-edited pictures below. Clicking the thumbprints will bring up the full-size pictures.

640 x 480 127k (taken indoors with regular ceiling, 2 bulb lighting)

640 x 480 80k (taken outdoors with early morning sunshine)

640 x 480 102k (taken indoors with florescent lighting)

320 x 240 31k (taken indoors with florescent lighting)

Even though the image quality of the PalmPix isn't the best in the world, I still think that it is a nifty little accessory for your Palm PDA. Of course you can get a throw away disposable point and shoot camera at any drug store, but having the ability to snap a picture almost anywhere and view it on the PDA immediately is priceless. 

Price: $99.95

Pros:
Portable
Easy to use

Cons:
No flash
Grainy pictures
Hard to use with IIIc in sunlight
No lens cap 

PalmPix for the Palm m100 Series
by Judie Clark

The PalmPix for the m100 only adds 1.25" (31.76mm) to the bottom of the Palm when installed. By itself, its dimensions are 1.9" (48.26mm) at it widest point on the side x .09" (22.87mm) thick x 3.3" (83.83mm) across the bottom. The PalmPix weighs 1.6 ounces without its battery. 

When I first received the PalmPix , I had a question in my mind: How could a digital camera that had no flash, fixed focus, and no viewfinder possibly hope to compete with the other more traditional digital cameras on the market today?

It took a trip to Hawaii to show me...

Like many tourists and vacationers, I wanted a photograph of almost everything that occurred on my family's trip. I didn't want to have to try to remember from scratch how happy my daughter looked as she enjoyed her first cup of vanilla macadamia nut coffee at an actual coffee plantation, or what the hanging bridge at Hanapepe looked like right before we made a mad dash across it. I didn't want to forget how the waterfall on our private hike cascaded down the rocks to the swimming hole underneath. I certainly didn't want to forget the local color and sites of the island of Kauai.

Knowing that I needed to review the PalmPix, I packed my Palm m100 in my bag, with the camera attached. I also brought my Sony Mavica FD-81, which is the digital camera I use every day.

I already knew before leaving that it would be unrealistic to compare the quality of the photos taken by either camera. However as I soon found out - it doesn't matter how great your regular camera's photos may or may not be - if you aren't willing to carry that camera with you everywhere, you will miss the "shot"... Every time.

I was very good at bringing both cameras with me when the family went out for the first day or so, but by the third day - I wasn't in the mood to lug the Mavica anywhere, anymore. I found that I was leaving it in the glove box of the car or back in our cabin at the Waimea Plantation most of the time - while the PalmPix, which fit almost weightlessly in my purse, was accompanying me everywhere.

One of the only "organized" things that we did on our vacation was enjoy the 4 hour hiking trip offered by the Princeville Ranch. We climbed hills, and made our way through an amazing forest filled with interesting flora and fauna, so that we could have lunch and enjoy swimming in a natural pool fed by a waterfall. Although it was chilly, we all managed to get in and have fun, splashing around. This picture of the waterfall itself, was taken on a slightly overcast day.

Imagine our surprise, when while out in the middle of no-where, we were joined by one of the thousands of chickens that roam the island. This particular rooster had two hens with him, and he was quite adept at trying to steal some of the delicious food our guide had brought. 

On our trek back, I was nursing a new blister, but I had to stop and marvel at the view of the mountains and valleys from the top of "our" hill. By now, it was quite overcast, and you can see that the picture is a bit dark. I was able to touch it up a bit later, using the included editing software.

  
(Left: Unmodified pic, Right: Modified pic)

On one day - we decided to check out the "Famous Hanging Bridge of Hanapepe."  It was sunny and beautiful outside, and I was able to get these shots of not only the bridge, but the water to its side. It was beautiful. After I took the pictures - we decided to run across the bridge - which made it sway and rock - too much fun! As we walked back, we noticed that some of the nails were coming up from the boards, so maybe running hadn't been the best idea...

  

I had never seen a coffee bush, much less a coffee plantation before, so it was a treat to visit the home of Kauai Coffee Company. It was amazing to see thousands of acres loaded with the tall coffee bushes. These picture was taken facing into the sun - so it is more exposed than it should have been...

And here is Sarah, enjoying that cup of vanilla macadamia nut coffee. She was sitting in the shadows, under an open slat-beam roof...

So there you have it. While the PalmPix won't be able to help me recall the "island music" that we enjoyed on a local station everyday, the pictures that I snapped with it certainly will help me remember what a fun time we had on our spring break.

Should this replace your regular digital camera? Definitely Not

However, if you can afford an extra camera, and you are wanting one that won't be a chore to remember to carry around, and if you are already using a PDA that it can be plugged into, then the Kodak PalmPix is a winner. You won't miss another shot.

Price: $99.95
Accessories are also available

Pros:
Extremely portable
Easy to use

Cons:
Expensive
No flash
Must be at least 36" away from subject
Pictures somewhat blurry/focus is iffy

Let me know your comments on the Kodak PalmPix for the Palm III and m100, and read what others have to say.