Official Gadgeteer Hands On Review: IR Blasters for Palm V and Palm III
by Julie Strietelmeier
Last date revised: 06/05/99

Program Requirements:
Device:
Palm V, Palm IIIx, Palm III, and Older PalmPilots that have been upgraded to the Palm III level with the 2meg upgrade board (with IR)
50 K free RAM for the OmniRemote software which is not included.

Tech Center Labs is always coming up with nifty little PalmPilot accessories. Their recent additions are called IR Blasters. These are small modules that can plug into a Palm V and a Palm III to increase the power of your IR signal for use with the Pacific Neo-Tek OmniRemote software. This software allows you to control IR devices like a TV, VCR, Satellite dish, etc. The software is not included with the IR Blaster, but a demo version can be downloaded from Pacific Neo-Teks website.

These IR Blasters are transmit only devices. They can not be used to receive IR signals either with learning commands from remote controls or to received beamed programs from other PalmPilot users. As a result you have to train the OmniRemote software using the built in IR first. Then you can switch it to use the external module.

The Palm V IR Blaster is a small black module that plugs into the hotsync port on the Palm V. It is made especially for the Palm V and will not fit any other Palm OS models.   It is solid and easy to connect and remove. The Palm V IR Blaster does not have a battery. Instead it steals power directly from the Palm V. The module does not take much power so you shouldn't notice your batteries draining faster than normal while using it.

irblaster1.jpg (4785 bytes) irblaster2.jpg (3885 bytes) irblaster3.jpg (2882 bytes)

There is also an IR Blaster for the Palm III. This is a larger module that also plugs into the hotsync port on the Palm III. This module does have a NiMH battery inside. The battery charge is kept topped off while it is plugged into the Palm III. Like the Palm V Blaster, this one is solidly made and also easy to insert and remove.

irblaster4.jpg (4214 bytes) irblaster5.jpg (3688 bytes)

I tested OmniRemote on my Palm V and Palm III with and without the IR Blaster module. After I had trained my three devices, I conducted a test to see how strong the internal Palm V and Palm III IR was versus the external IR Blaster modules. Here were my findings:

  Magnavox TV RCA VCR RCA DSS Satellite System
Palm III using internal IR 5ft 3ft 3ft
Palm III using Omniremote external IR module 7ft 14ft 12ft
Palm III using IR Blaster external IR module 10ft 12ft 11ft
Palm V using internal IR 2ft 2ft 3ft
Palm V using IR Blaster module 18ft 18ft 20ft

From my measurements, it seems that the Palm V with an IR Blaster works the best. The OmniRemote IR module and IR Blaster module for the Palm III seems to have about the same power. If you have a Palm III, you'll spend $29 for the IR Blasters from Tech Center Labs and then $20 for the OmniRemote software. That's a total of about $50. You can buy an IR module and OmniRemote software from Pacific Neotek for $40. Since Pacific Neotek's module has about the same signal strength as the IR Blaster, I think this is a better deal and it will save you about $10.  If you have a Palm V, you don't have that choice and will end up spending $50 buying the IR Blaster and software. Either way, you'll be happy if you choose the IR Blasters as they work as advertised.

Price: $29 each (OmniRemote software not included)

Pros:
It transmits a much stronger signal than the built in IR.

Cons:
Can not be used to learn IR commands. Built in IR must be used for that.
Only works with OmniRemote and not WedgeTV.

Let me know your comments on the IR Blasters and read what others have to say.