Product Requirements:
Device:
Windows PC 98, 2000, ME, XP or later

When I first saw pictures of the HP 1910 on the web, it really didn't give me much of a wow feeling. Then Judie and I saw one in person at the Fall Comdex in Las Vegas and it was love at first site for me. The screen was gorgeous and it was so small and cute! I knew I wanted one.

Two months have passed now, and in that time we've reviewed the Tungsten T, as well as the iPAQ 5455. Although the 5455 held a lot of promise, it just didn't 'do it' for me. The Tungsten T on the other hand continues to be my main PDA due to its size, overall stability and speed.

Thanks to Microsoft, I was lucky enough to acquire the 1910 for a 1.5 week review period. Marketed as a budget Pocket PC, this little guy definitely looks more like a Ferrari then a Ford. But does it have what it takes under the hood to make a decent Pocket PC? Let's find out...

Hardware Specifications

Operating System: Microsoft Pocket PC 2002
Processor: 200MHz Intel PXA 250 XScale
Memory: 64 MB SDRAM (46 MB user accessible), 16MB NAND Flash
Display Type: 16 bit, 64K color, 240 x 320, 3.8" diagonal, Transflective TFT liquid crystal display
Expansion: SD Memory Slot (Supports SD/MMC)
Infrared port: IrDA SIR
Audio: 2.5mm Stereo Mini Jack
Battery: lithium-polymer removable/rechargeable 900 mAH
Dimensions: (H x W x D): 4.46 x 2.75 x 0.50 in (113.3 x 69.9 x 12.7 mm)
Weight: 4.23 oz (120 g)

What's In The Box

HP 1910 Pocket PC
Removable Battery
2.5mm earbud earphones
CD (ActiveSync, Outlook 2000, Add-on applications)
Getting Started Guide
USB Sync cable
AC Adapter

After using the 5455 for a couple of weeks, going back to my Tungsten T made it seem like a midget. Then the HP 1910 showed up. Finally a Pocket PC that was truly Palm V sized. The Palm V seems to be the size by which all PDAs are still measured against. Now my Tungsten feels like a little brick in comparison.

[Top to bottom: HP 1910, Tungsten T, Palm m505]

[Top to bottom: HP 1910, Tungsten T, Palm m505]

This unit feels perfect in my hand. The size makes holding it very comfortable and there is enough heft to the unit to give it a quality feel. The 1910 is very solid. It didn't creak, crack or flex when squeezed it. I didn't notice any rattling while shaking it either.

The case is made of grey / silver plastic with a chrome colored plastic piping around the sides. It has a great look that is streamlined and classy. I also like the fact that the front is symmetrical around the display. iPAQs in the past have been wider on one side of the display. Yes, I'm being picky as usual...

Above the display is the Power switch / Alarm LED. I guess HP resurrected this feature from the old HP 500 series devices. The button itself is plastic and quite small. There isn't any tactile feedback associated with it, so I would often find myself pressing it more than once to activate it.

As far as the LED is concerned it, it glows solid amber when the battery fully charged, flashes amber while the battery is charging, and flashes green as an event alarm.

Below the LED is the display. And what a wonderful display it is! Bright, clear, crisp, and vivid are all adjectives that come to mind when I am viewing this gorgeous display. It actually employs the same type of display that the 5455 uses. Once you use a PDA with a transreflective display such as this one, it makes all other displays look washed out and dim. The 1910's display is so bright that I don't even run it at max brightness like I do on most all other PDAs that I own. Instead I run it at 75% brightness and it looks great. I could even comfortably run it at 50% but I like the little bit of extra light.

Unedited image taken with no flash and full brightness setting on the 1910]

The touch screen is adequately sensitive and easy to write on with a stylus. It is slick and does not feel spongy at all.

Below the display are the application buttons and the 5 way navigation pad. From left to right, the application buttons are mapped to the Calendar, Address Book, Mail and Today screen. The buttons themselves are flat and beveled at the bottom edge. The navigation pad sits between the application buttons. All of the buttons have excellent tactile feedback and protrude above the casing. I especially like the nav pad. It is a million times better than the one on the 5455. Four raised dots along edge help your thumb press in the appropriate direction of up/down, left or right. In the middle of the nav pad is a separate select button.

For gamers, the nav pad may be a bit small, but it is still usable for all but the most demanding action games.

On the left side of the unit there is a lanyard eyelet, IR port, voice record button and reset switch.

The IR port on the 1910 doesn't seem to be all that strong. I tested it with my Zayo and was only able to receive addresses from a maximum distance of 28 inches. I need to retest this with my 3800 iPAQ as I was unable to get the Zayo to receive addresses that I beamed from the 1910.

On the opposite side is the battery release switch. Like the 5455, the 1910 also has a replaceable rechargeable lithium ion battery. This is a great option as it allows you to switch out batteries during a long flight or road trip. You can purchase an extra for $50. At this time an extra capacity version is not available. It would be nice if they do decide to offer one in the future as the current batteries are only 900 mAH.

To see what battery life is like on the 1910, I conducted a couple tests. Results are below.

Wow, having the screen on while playing tunes really cuts down on the battery life!

After the first test, I charged the battery starting at 1pm. Charging was finished at 2:30pm.

2nd test (with screen turned off) results:

As you can see, there is a big difference in usage time while the screen is turned on as opposed when it is turned off.. It's really important to note that these kind of tests really don't give you the full picture with regards to real world battery life. A typical user will not be leaving their Pocket PC on for hours at a time. Instead they will turn it on for a few minutes, do some work and then turn it off. This type of usage will repeat throughout the day.

At the top of the 1910 is the earphone jack, microphone, SD slot and stylus silo.

In order to fit an earphone jack into the 1910, they used a smaller non-standard 2.5mm sized jack. Although a set of cheap 2.5mm earbuds are included, in order to use your favorite earphones with this PDA, you'll be required to purchase a 3.5mm to 2.5mm adapter from a store such as Radio Shack. I have no complaints regarding the sound quality thru headphones or the volume level thru headphones.

The built-in speaker volume on the unit is adequate. I found that I could listen to MP3s at about the 30% level and hear them just fine in an office setting. At the 100% level I found it more than loud enough for alarms and MP3 listening.

The voice recorder does a good job too.

Unfortunately, the SD slot built into the 1910 is not an SDIO slot. This means it can only be used for file storage purposes, and not for hardware add-ons such as digital cameras, Bluetooth, or WiFi adapters.

The stock stylus is actually not too bad. It's skinny of course, but it has a metal shaft which gives it a nice balance.

At the bottom of the unit is the sync / charge connector. This connector is actually the same one that the 3900 / 5400 series iPAQ use. Due to this fact, you can use previous iPAQ chargers with the 1910. But, for some very odd reason, they flipped the connector over. As a result, the 1910 will not fit in a standard iPAQ cradle. This isn't so bad since a sync cable is included with the unit. But, it also means that keyboards and other accessories will not work with the 1910. I find this to be pretty disappointing. I can't see any reason why they did this unless it was just to keep people from upgrading from the 3900 to the 1910 instead of the 5400...

As mentioned above, the 1910 is a budget PDA and as such, it doesn't have the speedy 400 MHz processor like the 5400 series. Instead it has a 200 MHz processor. Comparing the speed of the 1910 with my 400 MHz Zayo, I really didn't feel all that much of a difference with typical PIM tasks. Starting applications and switching between them felt pretty much the same. Where I could notice that the 1910 was slower was in viewing JPG images using Pocket IE. On the Zayo, a 122K .jpg loaded and displayed almost instantly, while the same file took 2 seconds or so to fully load on the 1910.

Now we get to the software side of things. The software bundle that comes with the 1910 is really more like a packet since there really isn't much to it...

Software Included in ROM:
Pocket Outlook - This is your PIM (Personal Information Manager) Suite of applications. You get Contacts, Calendar, Tasks, Notes, and Inbox. All of these applications will sync directly to Outlook on your desktop PC.

Pocket Internet Explorer - Web browser.

Pocket Word - View and edit Word documents.

Pocket Excel - View and edit Excel documents.

Block Recognizer - Graffiti clone input method. If you have a Palm OS PDA and know Graffiti, then you'll be right at home with this input method.

Voice Recorder, Calculator, Solitaire

Optional Software to install (included on CD):
Outlook 2000 - Desktop PIM.

Internet Explorer 6.0 - Windows desktop browser.

ActiveSync 3.5 (note: There is a newer version available online) - Syncing software.

Microsoft Money for the Pocket PC - Keep your financial accounts organized and synced with the desktop version.

Microsoft Reader 2.0 for Pocket PC - Read electronic books.

Microsoft Pocket Streets - Street-level mapping program.

Windows Media Player 8 for Pocket PC - Listen to digital music and watch movies.

Microsoft Transcriber - Handwriting recognition input method.

The 1910 has only 16MB of NAND Flash ROM. This type of memory is different than the type used in most Pocket PCs. The type of memory that we're used to dealing with is NOR Flash. The NOR type allows you to run programs directly from ROM. The NAND type that the 1910 uses does not allow you to do this. Instead, applications are copied from ROM to RAM and then executed. That's why even though the 1910 is a 64mb device, you only have ~47mb available to you. The other 16mb is reserved to run applications in. The 16mb of ROM is also not large enough to hold all of the Pocket PC 2002 applications. Applications such as Windows Media Player, MSN Messenger, Terminal Services Client, and Reader are not included and must be installed manually.

Out of the box my 1910 had 46.74 free space divided into 22.97 storage, and 18.98 program. Since I don't use MSN Messenger, Terminal Services Client or Reader on my Pocket PCs, so the only thing I installed was the Media Player. After installing that, I was left with: 21.92 storage and 18.97 program. If you are going to be a 1910 owner, you're definitely going to want an SD card!

I think the 1910 is a beauty. I know it's far from perfect, but I just can't help but love it. Sure it doesn't have as much built-in RAM as higher priced Pocket PCs, a Compact Flash or even an SDIO slot, but it is so small that I found myself taking it with me more often then a larger PDA. I'm also spoiled at viewing any other PDA display now that I've had a week with the 1910. I know for the same price you can buy the Dell Axim and get a faster processor, more memory, a SD and a CF slot. But for me personally, I would buy the 1910. The display and unit size are my most important factors in buying a PDA.

If you are a power Pocket PC user that wants to connect their Pocket PC to keyboards, GPS units, modems, and other peripherals, the 1910 is probably not going to be for you. But on the other hand, you are a typical user that mainly uses a PIM, likes to play a few games, listen to MP3s, read e-books, and prefers as small a Pocket PC as possible, this one might be just the one you've been looking for.

I'm dreading sending this unit back. I really want to keep it. <sniff>

 

Price: $299.99

Pros:
Gorgeous screen
Small size
Great price

Cons:
Small capacity battery
46mb of user memory
SD slot is not SDIO
No expansion capability other than SD memory